What "Not Retained" Means in Your Job Search and How to Bounce Back

Receiving a "not retained" status on your job application can be confusing and disheartening. This common rejection notification leaves many job seekers wondering what went wrong and how to move forward. Understanding the not retained meaning in job applications is crucial for improving your future job search strategies and maintaining resilience throughout your career journey.

The not retained meaning in job applications typically indicates that your application has been rejected and will not be kept on file for future consideration. While this rejection can be disappointing, understanding why it happens and how to respond constructively can transform this setback into a valuable learning opportunity.

‍

What Does "Not Retained" Mean in Job Applications?

When you receive a "not retained" status on your job application, it specifically means that the employer has decided not to move forward with your candidacy and will not be keeping your information for future job openings. This differs significantly from applications that are "kept on file," which indicates the company sees potential in your profile and may consider you for future positions.

The not retained meaning in the context of job applications is essentially a definitive rejection. Companies use this terminology in their automated responses to clearly communicate that the application process has concluded for you as a candidate. This status is typically delivered through Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS), which are software platforms that companies use to manage the hiring process.

Other similar terms employers might use instead of "not retained" include:

• "We have decided not to proceed with your application"
• "Your application was unsuccessful"
• "We will not be moving forward with your candidacy"
• "Your application has not been selected for further consideration"
• "We have chosen to pursue other candidates"

Understanding this terminology helps set proper expectations. When your application is not retained, it generally means you should focus your energy on other opportunities rather than waiting for a potential change of heart from this particular employer. However, this doesn't mean you can't apply to the same company for different positions in the future.

‍

Common Reasons Why Applications Are Not Retained

Understanding why employers decide not to retain applications can help you identify potential areas for improvement in your job search approach. Here are the most common reasons why applications receive this status:

ATS Algorithm Screening Failures

Modern hiring processes increasingly rely on Applicant Tracking Systems to manage the high volume of applications, specially when hiring for Software Developers. These systems use algorithms to scan resumes for specific keywords, qualifications, and formatting elements before a human ever sees them.

Common ATS-related reasons for not retained status include:

• Keyword mismatches: Your resume lacks the specific terms mentioned in the job description
• Formatting issues: Complex designs, tables, or headers/footers that confuse the ATS
• File type problems: Submitting in formats the system can't properly read
• Missing qualifications: The ATS flags your application as missing required skills or experience

Studies suggest that up to 75% of resumes are rejected by ATS systems before reaching human reviewers. Understanding how these systems work is crucial for modern job seekers.

Qualification and Experience Gaps

One of the most straightforward reasons for a not retained status is a mismatch between your qualifications and the job requirements. This includes:

• Missing technical skills: Lacking specific hard skills, certifications, or technical knowledge required for the role
• Insufficient experience: Not meeting the minimum years of experience or lacking experience in key areas
• Education requirements: Not having the required degree or educational background
• Industry-specific knowledge gaps: Lacking familiarity with industry-specific tools, regulations, or practices

Employers often have both explicit requirements (stated in the job description) and implicit requirements (unstated expectations) that influence their hiring decisions.

Application Material Issues

The quality and presentation of your application materials significantly impact retention decisions:

• Generic resumes and cover letters: Using the same materials for every application without customization
• Grammatical errors and typos: Mistakes that suggest carelessness or poor attention to detail
• Unprofessional presentation: Poor formatting, inconsistent styling, or difficult-to-read layouts
• Failure to address key requirements: Not clearly demonstrating how you meet the core job requirements
• Weak or missing achievements: Focusing on responsibilities rather than accomplishments and results

Your application materials are your first impression, and employers often use them as indicators of your professionalism and attention to detail.

Interview Performance or Pre-Screening Issues

For candidates who progress beyond the initial application review, interview performance or pre-screening assessments can lead to a not retained status:

• Poor interview preparation: Inability to effectively answer common interview questions
• Communication challenges: Difficulty articulating thoughts clearly or professionally
• Failed skills assessments: Underperforming on technical tests or job-specific evaluations
• Cultural fit concerns: Perceived misalignment with company values or team dynamics
• Unprofessional behavior: Inappropriate comments, tardiness, or lack of engagement

These factors become particularly important in later stages of the hiring process when employers are evaluating not just your skills but also how you'll fit into their organization.

Company-Specific Factors

Sometimes, the not retained meaning has little to do with your qualifications and more to do with internal company circumstances:

• Internal candidates: The company already had an internal candidate in mind
• Position changes or cancellations: The role was modified or eliminated during the hiring process
• Hiring freezes: Budget constraints or organizational changes paused hiring
• Overqualification concerns: Employers worried you might be too experienced and leave quickly
• Timing issues: The need to fill the position quickly led to choosing a more immediately available candidate

These factors are largely beyond your control but understanding them can help you maintain perspective when facing rejection.

‍

The Emotional Impact of Rejection and How to Process It

Receiving a not retained status can trigger a range of emotional responses. Understanding and managing these feelings is crucial for maintaining momentum in your job search.

Common Emotional Responses

Job seekers typically experience several emotions when facing rejection:

• Disappointment: The natural letdown after investing time and hope in an application
• Self-doubt: Questioning your qualifications, skills, or career path
• Frustration: Especially after multiple rejections or when no specific feedback is provided
• Anxiety: Worry about financial security or career prospects
• Embarrassment: Particularly if you shared your application process with others

These reactions are entirely normal and shared by job seekers at all career levels.

Healthy Ways to Process Rejection

To manage these emotions constructively:

1. Acknowledge your feelings: Allow yourself to feel disappointed without judgment
2. Maintain perspective: Remember that rejection is part of the process, not a reflection of your worth
3. Separate identity from outcome: Your value isn't determined by job application results
4. Seek support: Discuss your feelings with trusted friends, family, or mentors
5. Practice self-care: Maintain physical and mental health through exercise, adequate sleep, and relaxation techniques

According to career experts, the average job seeker faces 10-20 rejections before receiving an offer. Understanding this can help normalize the experience and reduce its emotional impact.

‍

Strategies to Improve Future Applications

After processing the emotional aspects of rejection, it's time to focus on practical strategies to improve your future applications and reduce the likelihood of receiving a not retained status.

Optimizing Resumes and Cover Letters for ATS

To increase your chances of passing ATS screening:

• Use keywords strategically: Incorporate relevant terms from the job description naturally throughout your resume
• Choose ATS-friendly formatting: Stick to standard fonts, avoid tables, text boxes, and complex designs
• Select proper file formats: Submit in recommended formats (usually .docx or .pdf, depending on instructions)
• Use standard section headings: "Work Experience," "Education," "Skills," etc.
• Include a skills section: List relevant technical and soft skills that match the job requirements

Before example:

CAREER ACHIEVEMENTS

• Drove 300% growth in Q4

• Managed cross-functional teams

• Implemented cutting-edge solutions

After example (ATS-optimized):

WORK EXPERIENCE

Marketing Manager | XYZ Company | 2018-2022

• Increased quarterly sales by 300% through strategic digital marketing campaigns

• Led cross-functional teams of 12 members to launch 5 successful product lines

• Implemented CRM solutions resulting in 45% improvement in customer retention

Tailoring Applications to Specific Positions

Generic applications often lead to not retained status. Instead:

• Research the company thoroughly: Understand their mission, values, products, and culture
• Analyze the job description: Identify key requirements, responsibilities, and preferred qualifications
• Customize your resume for each position: Highlight relevant experiences that directly address job requirements
• Write targeted cover letters: Address specific company needs and explain how your experience solves their problems
• Quantify achievements: Use numbers and metrics to demonstrate impact in previous roles

This customization shows employers you're genuinely interested in their specific opportunity rather than mass-applying to any available position.

Skill Development and Credential Building

If qualification gaps are leading to not retained statuses:

• Identify skill gaps: Compare your qualifications to those commonly requested in your target roles
• Pursue relevant certifications: Look for industry-recognized credentials that validate your skills
• Take online courses: Platforms like Coursera, LinkedIn Learning, and edX offer affordable skill development
• Volunteer for projects: Gain practical experience through pro bono work or community involvement
• Join professional associations: Access industry-specific training and networking opportunities

According to LinkedIn data, professionals who regularly update their skills are 13 times more likely to be hired compared to those who don't.

Networking and Relationship Building

Networking can help you bypass the traditional application process where not retained decisions often occur:

• Attend industry events: Connect with professionals in your field at conferences and meetups
• Leverage social media: Build a professional presence on LinkedIn and engage with industry content
• Schedule informational interviews: Learn from professionals in your target roles or companies
• Join online communities: Participate in industry-specific forums and discussion groups
• Reconnect with former colleagues: Maintain relationships with past coworkers who might provide referrals

Employee referrals are typically hired 55% faster than candidates who apply through job boards, making networking one of the most effective ways to avoid the not retained status.

‍

How to Request and Use Feedback After Rejection

While not all employers provide feedback, seeking constructive input can help you understand the specific reasons behind a not retained decision.

When and How to Request Feedback

To appropriately request feedback:

• Timing matters: Send your request within 24-48 hours of receiving the rejection
• Be concise and specific: Ask for one or two areas where you could improve
• Express gratitude: Thank them for considering your application and for any feedback they can provide
• Make it easy: Keep your request brief and straightforward
• Be professional: Avoid sounding defensive or entitled

Sample email template:

Subject: Thank you for the opportunity

‍

Dear [Hiring Manager's Name],

‍

Thank you for letting me know about your decision regarding the [Position] role. While I'm disappointed I won't be joining your team, I appreciate the time you took to consider my application.

‍

I'm committed to growing professionally and would greatly value any feedback you might be willing to share about my application or interview performance. Any insights on areas where I could improve would be extremely helpful for my professional development.

‍

Thank you again for your consideration, and I wish you and the team continued success.

‍

Best regards,

[Your Name]

Interpreting and Applying Feedback

When you receive feedback:

• Look for patterns: If you receive similar feedback from multiple sources, prioritize addressing those areas
• Be objective: Try to view feedback as valuable information rather than criticism
• Create an action plan: Develop specific steps to address the feedback
• Seek clarification if needed: If feedback is vague, consider asking follow-up questions for more specificity
• Express appreciation: Thank the person for taking the time to provide insights

If you don't receive feedback from the employer of the recruitment agency, conduct a self-assessment by reviewing your application materials and interview performance against the job requirements.

‍

Developing Resilience in Your Job Search

Building resilience is crucial for maintaining momentum despite receiving not retained statuses during your job search.

Maintaining Motivation Despite Rejection

To stay motivated:

• Set process goals: Focus on actions within your control (e.g., "Apply to five relevant positions weekly") rather than outcome goals
• Track progress: Document all job search activities to visualize your efforts
• Celebrate small wins: Acknowledge each step forward, like securing an interview or improving your resume
• Establish a routine: Create a structured job search schedule to maintain momentum
• Find an accountability partner: Connect with someone who can provide support and encouragement

Building Mental Toughness

To develop resilience:

• Practice positive self-talk: Challenge negative thoughts with realistic, constructive alternatives
• Visualize success: Imagine yourself succeeding in interviews and receiving offers
• Learn from each experience: After each rejection, identify one thing you can improve next time
• Maintain perspective: Remember that many successful professionals faced numerous rejections
• Focus on growth: View the job search as a skill you're developing rather than a test you're passing or failing

Famous examples of resilience include J.K. Rowling (rejected by 12 publishers before Harry Potter was accepted) and Walt Disney (fired from a newspaper for "lacking imagination"). These stories remind us that rejection often precedes success.

‍

When to Pivot Your Job Search Strategy

Sometimes, consistently receiving not retained statuses indicates a need to reassess your approach.

Signs It's Time to Change Tactics

Consider pivoting when:

• High volume of rejections: You've applied to numerous positions with similar results
• Consistent feedback patterns: You receive the same constructive criticism repeatedly
• No interviews: Your applications consistently fail to progress beyond initial screening
• Industry shifts: Changes in your target field make your current approach less effective
• Misalignment with goals: Your current target roles don't align with your skills or interests

Effective Pivot Strategies

When changing direction:

• Consult with career professionals: Seek guidance from career counselors or industry mentors
• Conduct informational interviews: Speak with professionals in adjacent fields or roles
• Explore related positions: Identify roles that require similar skill sets but may have different titles
• Consider contract or freelance work: Build experience through alternative employment arrangements
• Invest in reskilling: Pursue education or training for emerging roles in your field

A strategic pivot isn't giving up—it's making an informed decision to redirect your efforts toward more promising opportunities.

‍

Ready to Transform Your Job Search Experience?

Tired of facing the "not retained" status in your job applications? At Lupa, we understand the frustration of job rejection and the importance of finding the right match between talented professionals and quality companies.

Our approach focuses on quality connections rather than volume, ensuring that candidates are matched with positions where they'll genuinely succeed. We believe in transparent, human-centered recruiting that respects both candidates and employers.

Contact Lupa today to experience a recruiting process built on integrity, cultural understanding, and genuine care for your professional journey.

‍